Back Translation: the Key to Absolute Accuracy in Medical Translation?

22 07 2014

The root meaning of “translation”, deriving from the Latin translatio, is approximately “to carry across”. Significantly, the word does not imply equivalency, but rather an effort to take something into a new realm, results uncertain. When a translator “carries” a text from one language to another, errors are possible. Even without errors, semantic variations are common – one linguist’s translation is unlikely to ever be identical to another’s. This is why translation is often considered an “art,” and its practitioners are essentially artists with different perspectives, levels of understanding, and linguistic skills.

Medical Translation

But when the accuracy of medical or pharmaceutical documents explaining drugs, instruments, or specialized processes is vulnerable to human errors, people start wanting to structure translation into a science of absolutes. Because errors or unclear explanations can be life threatening in some fields, especially medical translation, “back translation” is sometimes used as an extra step in the quality assurance (QA) process. In fact, the World Health Organization (WHO) provides a detailed protocol for the process on its website:

WHO’s recommendation requires several analyses by multiple experts, an effort to pin language down in as precise and scientific a manner as possible. Most back translation is simpler. A forward translation from English to Spanish, for example, is back-translated by a translator unaware of the original, and this new English version is compared to the original to see what did and didn’t come out “equal.” “Reconciliation” then smoothes choices into a final draft of the original.

Theoretically, back translation gives valuable feedback to those on the source language end who need to know what their translation is saying to its foreign audience. It’s a controversial QA choice in that it requires a lot of resources, and some professionals question whether it’s truly more effective than standard editing and proofreading. A common complaint by these professionals is that in the end, back translation adds to the number of people involved, and thus increases the diversity of language interpretations and ideas about expression that have to be integrated. But it may be precisely in that point that the benefit exists: more analysis, more discussion, and more winnowing away of language differences, ideally produce something like an inarguable common denominator.

For most situations, highly experienced translators provide the level of linguistic and cultural accuracy required, without back translation, and because of the extra cost and time involved, global translation companies like Skrivanek find that the process is generally only ordered by medical companies. But for translations in which the slightest shade of misinterpretation could cost lives, back translation provides assurance that every conceivable tool has been used to ensure accuracy.

 J. McShulskis




4 responses

24 07 2014
Monica Colangelo (@trixiemck)

Back translation was invented by someone who had no idea what translation, languages and linguistics are about.

27 07 2014

And your conclusion is?

19 07 2017
Sharon James

Entire information in the content is very interesting. Certified health experts and interpreters are in extreme demand nowadays. Most medical and health care practices provide patients with the invaluable service from a certified medical or health care interpreter. One can take medical document translation service from NAATI certified agency.Thanks for sharing !!!

29 08 2017
Bily Stephen

Thanks for sharing very revelatory information. Back translation becomes important when you have high-value content that you need to be translated across languages with as much certainty as possible that the exact meaning is conveyed. We can go with professional translation services for medical document translation for accurate results.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: